Identify, restore, fix and enjoy vintage fountain pens

Vintage Pen Inspection Checklist

Buying Vintage Pens · Last reviewed 2026-11-21

Quick answer

Check for cracks at cap lips and lever slots, imprint sharpness, nib condition (tines, tipping, bends), brassing on trim, discoloration of celluloid or hard rubber, cap fit, clip condition and filler function. Ask for close-ups of anything you can't see.

In-hand checks

When the pen arrives, check cap fit, look for cracks with a light, inspect the nib with a loupe, and test the filler with water before ink.

CheckWhat to look for
CracksCap lip, lever slot, threads
ImprintSharp and readable adds value
NibAligned tines, intact tipping, no bends
TrimBrassing, dents
MaterialDiscoloration, ambering, shrinkage
FillerRestored? Works?
Cap fitSecure, not loose

Find it on eBay

Check sold prices, seller feedback, clear photos of the nib and imprints, whether the pen is restored, and the return policy.

Links go to eBay search results. We may earn a commission.

Common questions

Can cracks be seen in photos?

Often, with good lighting; ask for close-ups of cap lips and lever slots.

Is discoloration a problem?

It affects value but not always writing.